Etiquette mavens are the first to point out that gifts should not be
expected. Even so, there are plenty of situations where you'd better not show up
without one.
Strictly speaking, kids' birthdays, showers and weddings are the only parties
where presents are part of the etiquette-sensitive agenda. When it's not at
events like 60th wedding anniversaries, housewarmings, and such - gifts are kind
but unnecessary.
"Bringing presents to parties, unless they are children's birthday parties or
bridal or baby showers, where opening them is part of the entertainment, is a
terrible idea," Miss Manners (a.k.a. Judith Martin), writes in Miss Manners'
Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behavior, (Atheneum, New York 1982). "Any other
presents should be sent, so that the person who is trying to give a party or get
married or whatever can have her hands free."
If guests arrive - present in hand - to a fete that's supposed to be
gift-free, Miss Manners and other etiquette experts suggest quietly explaining
that the host or hostess has to deal with party details. To keep from
embarrassing other revelers who didn't show up with something, either open the
gift inconspicuously or keep it for after and follow up with a thank you note.
Remember: "No presents" means just that. Don't embarrass other guests by
popping up with bows and ribbons. If you're compelled to give, drop it off or
send it well before the fiesta begins, advise Nancy Tuckerman and Nancy Dunnan,
authors of The Amy Vanderbilt Complete Book of Etiquette (Doubleday, New York,
1995).
For your convenience, here's a thumbnail sketch of etiquette-wise gift
opening by party type:
Kids' Parties
Do it early, planners say. Kids get pooped - and cranky - pretty quick. As
energy wanes, so do attention spans and pint-sized manners. (Note: In
particularly polite circles, the birthday kid opens after guests go home. This,
according to one Manhattan society mom, prevents the child from making
ungrateful gift-specific comments in front of friends and their parents.)
Bar/Bat Mitzvahs
Often money or bonds, these gifts are easily sent before and opened after.
Adult Birthdays
Free-spirited sorts start unraveling the minute the present hits their hands.
More convivial friendly gatherings or family affairs often take a post-cake
time-out to survey the pickin's. More discrete recipients let the suspense build
by waiting until after guests.
Showers
Gifts are either the highlight - or the downfall - of showers. To make sure the
wrap falls before guests get bored, set up a destruction line: A mom or
bridesmaid to fetch gifts from the table, bride (with or without groom) to open
and thank effusively, maid of honor to note gifts on the cards.
Weddings
Since the couple takes center stage, wrapped gifts are displayed on a table and
opened after. Couples can opt to "show" gifts at a small open house or tea right
after the wedding. Experts like Miss Manners suggest just using the gifts in
their proper places, so that everybody who drops by will see how much they're
loved.
Anniversaries
Many couples are so settled that they prefer the social scene over presents, and
will note as much on the invite. Nevertheless, it's another situation where
gifts should be opened after.
Christmas/Holidays
It's best to follow familial tradition here. If it's a new group, work out the
logistics together. It's fairly typical to do an activity, from dinner to ice
skating first, before making mincemeat of the wrap.